CJ Lucas
I have had mine go goofy also. It has been everything from bad connections, dirty anodes, too much electrolyte, not enough electrolyte, burned up battery charger and anything else you may think of. Only once I had too much electrolyte, but that is definitely not your problem.
Eliminate the easy ones first. Check all your connections, especially the one where the wire meets the clamp. Next check your battery charger with an amp/volt meter. If that doesn't help try adding some (if you are using) washing soda. If you over do it you will get too many amps, not too few.
If that doesn't do it, start over. New solution, new anodes, better connections.
And finally, if that doesn't do it, sacrifice a chicken, stand on your left foot, poke your right eye with your left index finger, while jumping up and down shouting I hate this hobby.
Good luck,
Jack