I bought this today in Elijay for $15. Seems to be in great shape. I came home and put it in the lye until my wife went to bed. I just washed it off ... and as I was washing it, I was thinking this might be the smoothest pan I have! ... But as I was drying it, I started noticing a similar color that I had on my Experimental #5. Now I'm wondering if somebody used some power tools on it to smooth out some rough spots. It has a silvery look in some spots. It will be interesting to see what it looks like after a round of fresh seasoning...