Need advice for rough BSR #8

AlfredoJ

New member
Hello all. We already have two BSR skillets. One 7 Red Mountain and a #10. Both of these are super smooth and a joy to cook on. The #10 shows mill marks. The other day my son found a rusty MADE IN USA #8. We removed the rust using 50/50 vinegar and water soak (3 days). Before that, we used Easy Off oven cleaner to strip off the old seasoning. We ended up with a bare metal pan. When we first got it we noticed it was not smooth like the other two. Hoping that stipping and cleaning it up would reveal another smooth cooking surface. That was not to be. I did a little research and found that the newer 80s/90s BSRs were not milled. So enough background.

My question to the community is, should we sand it down to make it smoother? I don't want a mirror finish, but we would like a nice smooth surface. I've oven-seasoned it only twice using grape seed oil. We're not collectors; we want to cook with it. What do you all think? Thanks in advance.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1955.jpeg
    IMG_1955.jpeg
    271.1 KB · Views: 16
  • IMG_1954.jpeg
    IMG_1954.jpeg
    166.4 KB · Views: 16
  • IMG_1953.jpeg
    IMG_1953.jpeg
    192.1 KB · Views: 16
I wouldnt sand or grind it. Just LOTS of use and it will be smooth . I have a newer Lodge #14, it was rough at first, being new. But I use it a lot, and its as smooth as my Wapaks. I also have a #12 Wapak that I bought knowing it was pitted pretty bad. After 4 years of use off and on, its almost filled in. I use PAM in between uses,but I wipe it all back off,if that makes sense?
 
BSR offered skillets in both plain or "AA" (or "A") polished finishes up through at least the late 1980s, perhaps later.
 
Back
Top